How Retailers Can Win Customers When the Buyer Isn't Human

By Pini Yakuel, CEO, Optimove

Retailers are faced with a new question: How do you build a relationship with a customer when the buyer isn't human?


I was talking recently with one of our executives when she mentioned she'd been looking for theater tickets. She didn't browse ticketing sites or scroll through reviews. She asked an AI assistant, which searched shows, dates and seats and laid out her best options. She hasn't let it buy the tickets yet, but she said that's probably next. It turns out she now uses AI the same way for other shopping.


She's far from alone. Our own 2026 Optimove research, a survey of more than 600 consumers, found that 72% of U.S. shoppers now use AI tools such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini for shopping ideas or gift recommendations, and nearly half do so regularly. A new McKinsey survey revealed that more than half of shoppers now use AI to shop, corroborating what we found.


Increasingly, AI isn't just helping people decide what to buy. It's starting to do the buying. In the U.S., the share of AI users who completed a purchase directly through an AI tool rose from 10% to 17% in one year, according to McKinsey. This holiday season, AI agents will place orders on behalf of millions of shoppers.

The agent gets your catalog. You keep the relationship. That relationship is what gives a customer a reason to choose you again.

— Pini Yakuel, CEO, Optimove

For two decades, marketing followed a predictable sequence: search, ad, site visit, browse, compare, buy. Every step was a chance to make an impression.


AI compresses that sequence into a single request. According to McKinsey, 81% of AI users say AI does a good job narrowing their choices. In my opinion, AI is becoming everyone's new friend, and an increasingly influential source in their purchase decisions.


The agent doesn't see your ads or remember your brand. That means many shoppers will meet your brand for the first time after the purchase has already happened.

The Post-Purchase Moment Matters Most

The Path to Purchase Has Collapsed

The holidays are when brands meet the most new customers. Our data covering more than 5.5 million customers shows new customers jumped 593% on Black Friday 2025 compared with an average day, and 404% on Cyber Monday. And 47% of shoppers say they plan to try new brands this season.


As more of those first purchases are made by an AI agent, the brand's first real conversation with that customer won't be an ad or a homepage. It will be the order confirmation, the welcome email and the first product recommendation. Each one has to feel personal.

Recognize the Customer, Not Just the Order

Retailers need to seize the moment. That means connecting every signal, including a purchase an agent made, to a real person with a history, preferences and a likely next need.


A shopper who has bought running shoes three times might be back to restock, or to browse outdoor jackets for the first time. Those are two different moments that need two different responses.

At holiday scale, no team can manage this by hand. It takes real-time data and AI decisioning to choose the right message, offer, channel and timing for each customer.

Protect Your Relationship Data

Key Takeaways

Our recommendation in working with retailers is to make product information, pricing and inventory widely available so agents can recommend and transact. But treat customer information, purchase history and loyalty data as assets that need greater protection.


Put simply: The agent gets your catalog. You keep the relationship. That relationship is what gives a customer a reason to tell their agent to choose you next time.

Agentic commerce is still early. Agentic checkout remains a small share of total sales, and OpenAI reportedly scaled back its instant checkout plans this year. But retailers who prepare now will shape the shift rather than react to it. Agents follow instructions, and the brands that win repeat business will be the ones customers name.


In the end, retailers need to ensure the relationship is with the human, not the agent.