This Holiday Season, AI Will Find Your Customers. What Happens Next Is On You

By Sara Richter, CMO, SAP Engagement Cloud

This peak season, shoppers are arriving at your storefront differently. Consumers are increasingly turning to AI to research gifts, compare options, and build shortlists before deciding what to buy.


According to SAP’s latest Global Customer Loyalty Index 2026 research, 38% of consumers have used AI to make purchase decisions, a third have bought a product directly recommended by an AI assistant, and 32% prefer AI recommendations over advice from friends and family.


For retail brands, this shift puts the focus on what Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and the wider holiday season demand. AI is delivering more potential customers than ever before. But visibility is not the same as loyalty. Increasingly, the real competition will be won or lost in everything that happens after discovery.



When a holiday shopper arrives through an AI recommendation, they come primed to buy and primed to judge. They have already compared options. What they want now is for your brand to deliver on whatever brought them there.


The reasons customers choose to stay with a brand remain constant. 60% of consumers are more loyal to brands that make them feel personally valued, and almost two-thirds (62%) cite product quality as a key driver.


What has changed is the tolerance for falling short. 36% have switched from a brand they were previously loyal to following a single poor customer experience. In the compressed timelines of peak season, these shortfalls can take on even more weight. One out-of-stock disappointment, one irrelevant message, or one frustrating return can end a relationship before it has really started.

For retail brands finalising plans right now, the fastest gains come not from adding more campaigns, but from deploying AI capabilities that are most likely already available in their technology stack and are perhaps underused.


Switch from static lists to predictive segments. If your Black Friday audiences are still built on demographic or transactional filters, AI-powered predictive segments — built on lifecycle stage, purchase propensity, spend level, and churn risk — will immediately sharpen who gets what. For price-sensitive segments, a targeted offer makes sense. For your most loyal customers, early access or a loyalty moment is almost always a better play than a blanket discount.


Let AI decide when to send. During Black Friday and Cyber Monday, inboxes are at their most congested. Send Time Optimisation analyses each individual customer's historical engagement to deliver messages in the window when they are most likely to open. In a period where every open matters, it is one of the easiest AI capabilities to switch on — and one of the most immediately impactful.


Make your triggers smarter. Browse abandonment, cart recovery, post-purchase follow-up — if these journeys are serving generic content rather than real-time, AI-driven product recommendations based on each customer's behaviour and predicted next purchase, they are significantly underperforming their potential. During the highest-intent days of the season, that relevance is often the difference between a conversion and a lost sale.

These actions can make a difference at this stage of the game. But the bigger prize lies beyond this holiday season. The instinct in retail marketing is to focus everything on the campaign build-up. That work matters — but the brands that will perform after peak season understand that the real work begins when the transaction completes.


To do that retail brands need to work to connect their operational and customer data, so marketing reflects what's happening across the business. It involves building post-purchase journeys that treat shoppers, at any time of year, as the start of a relationship, not the end of a transaction. And it means using agentic AI not just to generate traffic, but to act on real intent signals in the moments that matter.


AI has changed how customers find you. What it has not changed is why they stay. Brands that understand the difference and build their operations around it, will be turning this holiday season’s new shoppers into next year's loyal customers.


Consumer expectations have shifted — but the fundamentals of loyalty have not

Key Black Friday actions to take now

Beyond the holidays: the bigger prize

AI is delivering more potential customers than ever before. But visibility is not the same as loyalty. The real competition will be won or lost in everything that happens after discovery.

— Sara Richter, CMO, SAP Engagement Cloud